How to Select the Perfect Cheese for Authentic Detroit-Style Pizza

It is the perfect cheese for authentic Detroit-style pizza. The crispy, caramelized cheese edges represent more than just a happy accident—they showcase an art form that begins with proper cheese selection. My years of perfecting this recipe have taught me that cheese choice determines the success of this iconic dish.

Wisconsin brick cheese is the cornerstone of traditional Detroit-style pizza. The challenge lies in finding this specific ingredient consistently. Understanding authentic options and practical substitutes becomes essential. In this piece, let me share everything about selecting the perfect Cheese for your Detroit-style pizza—from classic brick cheese combinations to creative alternatives that create those signature crispy edges.

Understanding Detroit Pizza Cheese Fundamentals

Detroit-style pizza cheese has some unique qualities worth sharing. The technique starts with cheese application that extends edge-to-edge to cover the surface completely. This method creates those irresistible, crispy, caramelized edges everyone craves.

Wisconsin brick cheese stands out as the centerpiece – a semi-hard cowcow’seese named after the bricks used to press it. This Cheese brings several significant qualities to Detroit-style pizza:

Mild and buttery flavor that becomes more tangy as it ages
High-fat content that creates a naturally buttery crust
Superior melting properties with minimal greasiness
It creates perfect bubbling and caramelization

My experience shows that cheese moisture content is a vital factor to consider. Low-moisture varieties work best because excess water can impact the doudough’sdough’socess. Blending brick cheese with low-moisture mozzarella delivers the ideal balance of flavor and texture.

The baking process transforms the Cheese. Its high-fat content melts into the crust and creates that distinctive buttery flavor Detroit-style pizza is known for – without adding butter! Steam from the Cheese forms tiny air pockets that result in the sought-after bubbly surface.

Mastering Brick Cheese Selection

My first attempts at making Detroit-style pizza turned finding authentic Wisconsin brick cheese into a wealth of discoveries. Multiple calls to stores and cheese shops taught me valuable lessons about selecting this significant ingredient.

Authentic brick cheese comes in two varieties: young and aged. Detroit-style pizza needs the young, mild version because of its buttery flavor and superior melting properties. A 7-ounce block might set you back $7, but the investment delivers authentic taste and texture.

The best sourcing options for authenticity enthusiasts include:

Local specialty cheese shops (call ahead)
Online retailers (mainly to buy in bulk)
Wisconsin-based food services
Specialty grocery store cheese counters

The search for brick cheese shouldn’t be out. My experiments with alternatives have yielded excellent results. The best substitute combines mild Wisconsin cheddar with low-moisture mozzarella. Purists might raise eyebrows, but many Detroit pizzerias use Cheese blends themselves. An 80/20 mozzarella-to-brick cheese ratio creates that perfect balance of authentic flavor and ideal melting characteristics.

Note that a standard Detroit-style pizza needs about 12 ounces of Cheese, whether you have cheese or a blend. This generous amount might seem excessive, but it perfectly creates those signature crispy edges.

Creating Perfect Cheese Blends

My years of experimenting with different cheese combinations have taught me that creating the perfect blend mixes art and science. The search for alternatives began when authentic brick cheese was unavailable. Through testing, I found several combinations that give amazingly similar results.

The Perfect Substitute Blend combines equal parts low-moisture mozzarella and Monterey Jack cheese. The mozzarella delivers the clean, buttery dairy flavor we want, while Jack cheese adds fat content and tanginess to match brick checheese’sacharcheese’sicshese cheese combinations create authentic-tasting Detroit-style pizza:

Low-moisture mozzarella + Monterey Jack (50/50 ratio)
Low-moisture mozzarella + Muenster (60/40 ratio)
Mild Wisconsin cheddar + mozzarella blend (40/60 ratio)

Success with any of these combinations depends on your application technique. The Cheese needs complete edge-to-edge coverage to caramelize against the panpan’sdes. Pans Pans low moisture content is vital—it stops excess water from affecting your dough during baking.

These blends might not follow tradition, but they are most particularly Detroit-style pizza fans. It would be best to try adjusting these ratios to match your taste. Some of the best recipes emerge from creative experiments that honor the basic principles of Detroit-style pizza making.

Conclusion

The perfect Detroit-style pizza needs careful attention to cheese selection and how it is applied. Wisconsin brick cheese creates the ideal foundation, but my testing shows that creative alternatives can give equally impressive results. These cheese blends are a great way to get the signature crispy edges we love.

A few fundamental principles will help you succeed: pick low-moisture varieties, spread Cheese from edge to edge, and try different ratios. Your ideal blend is out there waiting.

Want to raise your Detroit-style pizza game? You can create exceptional bread and pizza with our authentic artisanal sourdough starter from The Yeast We Can Do. Our small-batch starter gives that perfect tangy flavor and signature crust that passionate home bakers and restaurant owners look for. It will reshape the scene of your baking. Email john@theyeastwecando.com to get our premium sourdough starter.

The right cheese blend and proper technique will help you become skilled at making Detroit-style pizza. These guidelines are just the beginning. Trust your instincts; your homemade pizzas will soon match those from your favorite Detroit pizzerias.

FAQs

What type of Cheese should be used for Detroit-style pizza?
Detroit-style pizza, known for its thick, pan-baked crust and crispy cheese edges, is traditionally made with Wisconsin brick cheese. This Cheese is applied before the sauce and spread to the very edges of the pan to create a characteristic frico crust.

Which Cheese is an excellent alternative to brick cheese?
If youyou’reoking for a substitute for brick cheese, consider using other smear-ripened cheeses like Limburger, Époisses, Tilsiter, Taleggio, or an aged Muenster. These cheeses share similar characteristics and can work well in recipes calling for brick cheese.

What is the preferred Cheese for Detroit-style pizza according to culinary enthusiasts?
Brick cheese is highly recommended for Detroit-style pizza due to its melting properties and flavor. However, if unavailable, low-moisture tiarella (preferably in block form) is a suitable alternative.

What can I use if I don’t dondon’teese for my Detroit pizza?
A blend of mozzarella with muenster or Monterey Jack can be used without brick cheese. This combination will mimic the taste and texture of a traditional brick and mozzarella cheese blend on Detroit-style pizza. Experimentation with different blends is also encouraged to suit personal taste preferences.